Easy Sociology
  • Sociology Hub
    • Sociology Questions & Answers
    • Sociology Dictionary
    • Books, Journals, Papers
    • Guides & How To’s
    • Life Around The World
    • Research Methods
    • Sociological Perspectives
      • Feminism
      • Functionalism
      • Marxism
      • Postmodernism
      • Social Constructionism
      • Structuralism
      • Symbolic Interactionism
    • Sociology Theorists
  • Sociologies
    • General Sociology
    • Social Policy
    • Social Work
    • Sociology of Childhood
    • Sociology of Crime & Deviance
    • Sociology of Culture
      • Sociology of Art
      • Sociology of Dance
      • Sociology of Food
      • Sociology of Sport
    • Sociology of Disability
    • Sociology of Economics
    • Sociology of Education
    • Sociology of Emotion
    • Sociology of Family & Relationships
    • Sociology of Gender
    • Sociology of Health
    • Sociology of Identity
    • Sociology of Ideology
    • Sociology of Inequalities
    • Sociology of Knowledge
    • Sociology of Language
    • Sociology of Law
    • Sociology of Media
      • Sociology of Anime
      • Sociology of Film
      • Sociology of Gaming
      • Sociology of Literature
      • Sociology of Music
      • Sociology of TV
    • Sociology of Migration
    • Sociology of Nature & Environment
    • Sociology of Politics
    • Sociology of Power
    • Sociology of Race & Ethnicity
    • Sociology of Religion
    • Sociology of Sexuality
    • Sociology of Social Movements
    • Sociology of Technology
    • Sociology of the Life Course
    • Sociology of Travel & Tourism
    • Sociology of Violence & Conflict
    • Sociology of Work
    • Urban Sociology
  • A-Level Sociology
    • Families
      • Changing Relationships Within Families
      • Conjugal Role Relationships
      • Criticisms of Families
      • Divorce
      • Family Forms
      • Functions of the Family
  • Featured Articles
  • About
    • Site News
    • Newsletter
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Contact Us
  • Log In
  • Join Now
No Result
View All Result
Easy Sociology
  • Sociology Hub
    • Sociology Questions & Answers
    • Sociology Dictionary
    • Books, Journals, Papers
    • Guides & How To’s
    • Life Around The World
    • Research Methods
    • Sociological Perspectives
      • Feminism
      • Functionalism
      • Marxism
      • Postmodernism
      • Social Constructionism
      • Structuralism
      • Symbolic Interactionism
    • Sociology Theorists
  • Sociologies
    • General Sociology
    • Social Policy
    • Social Work
    • Sociology of Childhood
    • Sociology of Crime & Deviance
    • Sociology of Culture
      • Sociology of Art
      • Sociology of Dance
      • Sociology of Food
      • Sociology of Sport
    • Sociology of Disability
    • Sociology of Economics
    • Sociology of Education
    • Sociology of Emotion
    • Sociology of Family & Relationships
    • Sociology of Gender
    • Sociology of Health
    • Sociology of Identity
    • Sociology of Ideology
    • Sociology of Inequalities
    • Sociology of Knowledge
    • Sociology of Language
    • Sociology of Law
    • Sociology of Media
      • Sociology of Anime
      • Sociology of Film
      • Sociology of Gaming
      • Sociology of Literature
      • Sociology of Music
      • Sociology of TV
    • Sociology of Migration
    • Sociology of Nature & Environment
    • Sociology of Politics
    • Sociology of Power
    • Sociology of Race & Ethnicity
    • Sociology of Religion
    • Sociology of Sexuality
    • Sociology of Social Movements
    • Sociology of Technology
    • Sociology of the Life Course
    • Sociology of Travel & Tourism
    • Sociology of Violence & Conflict
    • Sociology of Work
    • Urban Sociology
  • A-Level Sociology
    • Families
      • Changing Relationships Within Families
      • Conjugal Role Relationships
      • Criticisms of Families
      • Divorce
      • Family Forms
      • Functions of the Family
  • Featured Articles
  • About
    • Site News
    • Newsletter
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Contact Us
  • Log In
  • Join Now
No Result
View All Result
Easy Sociology
No Result
View All Result

The Concept of Religious Communes

Easy Sociology by Easy Sociology
May 24, 2025
in Sociology of Religion
Home Sociology of Religion
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on PinterestShare on RedditShare on Telegram

Table of Contents

  • Historical Origins of Religious Communes
  • Definitional Parameters
  • Methodological Approaches to Studying Religious Communes
  • Theoretical Lenses on Religious Communes
  • Comparative Case Studies
  • Internal Governance and Organisational Structures
  • Everyday Life and Ritual Practice
  • Intersectionality: Gender, Race, and Class in Communal Life
  • Boundary Maintenance and External Relations
  • Sustainability: Why Communes Thrive or Collapse
  • Digital Transformations and Neo‑Communes
  • Future Trajectories: Communes in the Age of Climate Crisis and AI
  • Conclusion

Religious communes—self‑contained communities organised around shared faith commitments—have fascinated sociologists since the discipline’s inception. They illuminate how belief, social organisation, economics, and culture intertwine to produce distinctive ways of living that challenge dominant social patterns. This article, written for undergraduate readers, expands on classical and contemporary scholarship to offer a comprehensive exploration of religious communes: their genealogy, social dynamics, theoretical explanations, and emergent futures. Along the way it probes methodological debates and comparative case studies, equipping readers with analytic tools to evaluate the promises and perils of collective religious life.

Historical Origins of Religious Communes

Deep Roots in World Religions

Long before the term commune entered sociological vocabulary, intentional religious communities dotted the global landscape. Early Christian monastic settlements, Buddhist sanghas, Jain śramaṇa orders, and Sufi lodges each pursued spiritual discipline through communal withdrawal. Although doctrinally distinct, these formations shared three impulses: the quest for heightened sacred experience, the regulation of desire through collective rule, and the cultivation of exemplary moral status vis‑à‑vis wider society.

European Monasticism and Proto‑Communes

In medieval Europe, Benedictine and Cistercian monasteries institutionalised rules of prayer, work, and silence, foreshadowing later Protestant and Anabaptist ventures. Their impact was twofold: internally, they created a template for “total institutions” whose architecture disciplined bodies; externally, they accumulated land and knowledge, thereby forging early networks of trans‑local exchange.

Nineteenth‑Century Utopian Experiments

The modern concept of the religious commune crystallised in the nineteenth century when utopian movements such as the Shakers, the Oneida Community, and the Amana Colonies combined millenarian theology with experiments in communal property and gender innovation. These projects responded to industrial capitalism, urban dislocation, and the Second Great Awakening’s revivalist fervour, offering holistic alternatives grounded in sacred injunctions. Their organisational blueprints—celibate equality among the Shakers, complex marriage at Oneida—functioned as both theological practice and social protest.

Twentieth‑Century Transformations

The twentieth century added Kibbutzim in Mandatory Palestine—melding Zionist nationalism with socialist religion—and countercultural American communes that blended Eastern mysticism with ecological and pacifist commitments. The Hutterite Bruderhöfe, displaced repeatedly by war, refined systems of inter‑colony fissioning to maintain demographic and cultural vitality. Each wave illustrates how socio‑historical conditions—migration, nationalism, economic upheaval—spur communal religious innovation while requiring adaptive resilience.

Definitional Parameters

Sociologists delineate religious communes by three overlapping criteria that together constitute a communal triad:

  1. Collective Residence: Members live in spatial proximity, often sharing dormitories or clustered housing within a bounded settlement whose spatial design encodes theological symbolism.
  2. Economic Pooling: Resources such as income, labour, and property are held in common or redistributed according to communal norms, thereby challenging capitalist notions of individual accumulation.
  3. Ideological Unity Grounded in Faith: A theological worldview legitimises collective rules, rituals, and identity, distinguishing the group from purely secular intentional communities.

These elements differentiate communes from ordinary congregations, which gather for worship but disperse for work and domestic life. Communes aspire to holistic integration—remaking the total social fact, to use Mauss’s expression—so that sacred meanings permeate labour, kinship, governance, and leisure.

Commune, Sect, or Monastery?

FeatureReligious CommuneSectarian CongregationMonastic Order
ResidenceShared settlementDispersed householdsEnclosed cloister
Economic ModelCommunal or mutualistIndividual livelihoodsCorporate endowment
MembershipFamilies & singlesIndividual believersCelibate members
Goal OrientationWorld‑transforming & world‑rejecting tendenciesSalvation within broader societySpiritual perfection through withdrawal

Methodological Approaches to Studying Religious Communes

Ethnography and Participant Observation

Ethnographic immersion remains the gold standard for capturing the texture of communal life—its smells, sounds, and affective cadences. Extended residence enables the researcher to observe how public piety interfaces with backstage tensions, a dimension often sanitised in official narratives.

Historical‑Comparative Analysis

Archival sources, oral histories, and longitudinal demographic data reveal trajectories of growth, schism, and decline. Comparative work across time and space—Shaker celibacy in nineteenth‑century New England versus celibate Catholic Worker houses in 1930s New York—uncovers how similar logics are adapted to distinct structural constraints.

Quantitative Demography and Network Analysis

Population censuses, fertility rates, and network matrices illuminate patterns of retention, defection, and kinship connectivity. For example, demographic‑network studies of Hutterite colonies demonstrate how fissioning at approximately 150 members sustains social intimacy while managing ecological capacity.

Reflexivity and Ethical Dilemmas

The researcher’s positionality—religious or secular; insider, outsider, or in‑between—shapes access and interpretation. Ethical quandaries emerge around confidentiality and the potential reproduction of stigma. Reflexive transparency is thus integral to sociological rigour.

Theoretical Lenses on Religious Communes

Durkheimian Solidarity Revisited

Durkheim’s concept of collective effervescence underscores how ritual synchrony builds mechanical solidarity. In communes, the high density of ritual practice—dawn prayers, communal meals, chore rotations—heightens emotional energy that is subsequently channelled into normative enforcement. Recent affect theory nuances this by foregrounding bodily resonance and micro‑gestures that sustain communal moods.

Weberian Charismatic Authority and Its Routinisation

Max Weber’s insights into charisma illuminate the founding charisma of leaders such as Mother Ann Lee or Rebbe Israel Meir Lau. Charisma’s fragility necessitates routinisation—codifying revelation into constitutions, appointing councils, and standardising liturgy. Failure to routinise often precipitates schism or dissolution, as seen in the post‑Joseph Smith Latter‑day Saint movement.

Marxist and Neo‑Marxist Critiques: Labour and Reproduction

Marx viewed communes as embryonic socialism but warned that ideological superstructures could mask exploitation. Neo‑Marxist feminists extend this critique by analysing domestic labour. For instance, studies on the Jesus People USA commune reveal how women’s reproductive labour sustains male public ministry, reproducing patriarchal hierarchies under egalitarian rhetoric.

Rational Choice and the Economy of Religion

Stark and Bainbridge conceptualise communes as high‑cost, high‑reward organisations that supply otherworldly compensators—promises of salvation—unavailable in low‑cost religious marketplaces. Costly commitments such as celibacy or communal property deter free riders, thereby stabilising collective goods like shared child‑care and economic insurance.

Post‑Colonial and Global South Perspectives

Emergent scholarship interrogates how Western categories of “commune” map onto Global South phenomena. Afro‑Brazilian terreiros, for instance, function as residential‑ritual hubs that blend Candomblé worship with economic cooperatives. Post‑colonial theorists caution against imposing Euro‑centric ideals of property and individuality onto these contexts.

Comparative Case Studies

Membership Required

You must be a member to access this content.

View Membership Levels

Already a member? Log in here
Tags: communal livingintentional communitiesreligious communessociology of religionutopian religious movements
Easy Sociology

Easy Sociology

Easy Sociology is your go-to resource for clear, accessible, and expert sociological insights. With a foundation built on advanced sociological expertise and a commitment to making complex concepts understandable, Easy Sociology offers high-quality content tailored for students, educators, and enthusiasts. Trusted by readers worldwide, Easy Sociology bridges the gap between academic research and everyday understanding, providing reliable resources for exploring the social world.

Related Articles

A close up of the Buddha statue

Mahayana Buddhism: An Academic Exploration

June 25, 2024

Mahayana Buddhism, one of the major branches of Buddhism, has had a profound impact on the spiritual, cultural, and social...

A church of scientology building with a large 'scientology' sign.

Scientology: An Outline and Explanation

February 24, 2024 - Updated on May 15, 2024

Learn about the origins, beliefs, organization, practices, controversy, and impact of Scientology. This blog post provides an in-depth analysis of...

Next Post
A feminist holding a placard saying 'i will not go back to the 1950's'.

Feminist Perspectives on Social Stratification: Gender, Power, and Inequality

An AI image of the blitz spirit

The Blitz Spirit: A Sociological Exploration of Collective Resilience in Wartime Britain

Rows of black chairs

What Were Education Action Zones in the UK?

Please login to join discussion

GET THE LATEST SOCIOLOGY

Get the latest sociology articles direct to you inbox with the Easy Sociology newsletter. (We don't spam or sell your email).

POLL

How Can We Improve Easy Sociology?

Recommended

A group of geeks on laptops

Focus Groups: An Overview

August 1, 2024
A bowl of sorcery ingredients

Sociology of Sorcery

October 29, 2024

24 Hour Trending

  • A statue of a revolver with the barrel twisted into a knot. Symbolic violence.

    Pierre Bourdieu’s Symbolic Violence: An Outline and Explanation

    2247 shares
    Share 899 Tweet 562
  • Understanding Communication in Sociology

    280 shares
    Share 112 Tweet 70
  • Understanding the Ideas of Anthony Giddens in Sociology

    588 shares
    Share 235 Tweet 147
  • The Role of Media in Primary Socialisation

    619 shares
    Share 248 Tweet 155
  • Understanding Conflict Theories in Sociology

    1551 shares
    Share 620 Tweet 388

Easy Sociology makes sociology as easy as possible. Our aim is to make sociology accessible for everybody.

© 2023 Easy Sociology

No Result
View All Result
  • Sociology Hub
    • Sociology Questions & Answers
    • Sociology Dictionary
    • Books, Journals, Papers
    • Guides & How To’s
    • Life Around The World
    • Research Methods
    • Sociological Perspectives
      • Feminism
      • Functionalism
      • Marxism
      • Postmodernism
      • Social Constructionism
      • Structuralism
      • Symbolic Interactionism
    • Sociology Theorists
  • Sociologies
    • General Sociology
    • Social Policy
    • Social Work
    • Sociology of Childhood
    • Sociology of Crime & Deviance
    • Sociology of Culture
      • Sociology of Art
      • Sociology of Dance
      • Sociology of Food
      • Sociology of Sport
    • Sociology of Disability
    • Sociology of Economics
    • Sociology of Education
    • Sociology of Emotion
    • Sociology of Family & Relationships
    • Sociology of Gender
    • Sociology of Health
    • Sociology of Identity
    • Sociology of Ideology
    • Sociology of Inequalities
    • Sociology of Knowledge
    • Sociology of Language
    • Sociology of Law
    • Sociology of Media
      • Sociology of Anime
      • Sociology of Film
      • Sociology of Gaming
      • Sociology of Literature
      • Sociology of Music
      • Sociology of TV
    • Sociology of Migration
    • Sociology of Nature & Environment
    • Sociology of Politics
    • Sociology of Power
    • Sociology of Race & Ethnicity
    • Sociology of Religion
    • Sociology of Sexuality
    • Sociology of Social Movements
    • Sociology of Technology
    • Sociology of the Life Course
    • Sociology of Travel & Tourism
    • Sociology of Violence & Conflict
    • Sociology of Work
    • Urban Sociology
  • A-Level Sociology
    • Families
      • Changing Relationships Within Families
      • Conjugal Role Relationships
      • Criticisms of Families
      • Divorce
      • Family Forms
      • Functions of the Family
  • Featured Articles
  • About
    • Site News
    • Newsletter
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Contact Us
  • Log In
  • Join Now

© 2025 Easy Sociology

We use information collected through cookies and similar technologies to improve your experience on our site, analyse how you use it and for marketing purposes.
Privacy Policy

Your privacy settings

We and our partners use information collected through cookies and similar technologies to improve your experience on our site, analyse how you use it and for marketing purposes. Because we respect your right to privacy, you can choose not to allow some types of cookies. However, blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience of the site and the services we are able to offer. In some cases, data obtained from cookies is shared with third parties for analytics or marketing reasons. You can exercise your right to opt-out of that sharing at any time by disabling cookies.
Privacy Policy
Allow all

Manage Consent Preferences

Necessary

Always ON
These cookies and scripts are necessary for the website to function and cannot be switched off. They are usually only set in response to actions made by you which amount to a request for services, suchas setting your privacy preferences, logging in or filling in forms. You can set your browser to block oralert you about these cookies, but some parts of the site will not then work. These cookies do notstore any personally identifiable information.

Analytics

These cookies and scripts allow us to count visits and traffic sources, so we can measure and improve the performance of our site. They help us know which pages are the most and least popular and see how visitors move around the site. All information these cookies collect is aggregated and therefore anonymous. If you do not allow these cookies and scripts, we will not know when you have visited our site.

Embedded Videos

These cookies and scripts may be set through our site by external video hosting services likeYouTube or Vimeo. They may be used to deliver video content on our website. It’s possible for the video provider to build a profile of your interests and show you relevant adverts on this or other websites. They do not store directly personal information, but are based on uniquely identifying your browser and internet device. If you do not allow these cookies or scripts it is possible that embedded video will not function as expected.

Google Fonts

Google Fonts is a font embedding service library. Google Fonts are stored on Google's CDN. The Google Fonts API is designed to limit the collection, storage, and use of end-user data to only what is needed to serve fonts efficiently. Use of Google Fonts API is unauthenticated. No cookies are sent by website visitors to the Google Fonts API. Requests to the Google Fonts API are made to resource-specific domains, such as fonts.googleapis.com or fonts.gstatic.com. This means your font requests are separate from and don't contain any credentials you send to google.com while using other Google services that are authenticated, such as Gmail.

Marketing

These cookies and scripts may be set through our site by our advertising partners. They may be used by those companies to build a profile of your interests and show you relevant adverts on other sites. They do not store directly personal information, but are based on uniquely identifying your browser and internet device. If you do not allow these cookies and scripts, you will experience less targeted advertising.
Confirm my choices Allow all
×